 An online database of WORLD WAR
II books and information
New & forthcoming
Books by subjects
Book search service
Book reviews
Recommended reading
Book forum
Latest book feedback
Catalog requests
Newsletter requests
Sell your books
War Diary
Armies
Nations at war
History
Trivia challenge
WWII links
About us
Site guide
Site index
On the Web since 1995
|
|
Goda, Norman J. W. Tomorrow the World: Hitler, Northwest Africa, and the Path toward America. College Station, TX: Texas A & M University Press, 1998
ISBN 0-89096-807-1
307 pages
Preface; Introduction; maps; Conclusion; Notes; Bibliography; Index.
Norman Goda's Introduction opens his new book with an arousing contention:
...historians of the Second World War have traditionally
argued...that Adolf Hitler's Germany had no more than an ephemeral interest
in Northwest Africa and no global designs against the United States. This
study will examine this very issue and will argue otherwise. From the
capitulation of France in 1940 to the Allied North African landings of
1942, the parameters of this book, Hitler's Germany tried consistently to
develop German bases in French North Africa and the outlying Spanish and
Portuguese islands. The bases were to be employed in a future struggle with
the United States.
Goda then proceeds in measured, scholarly fashion to review the political,
diplomatic, military, and economic policies of Germany, Vichy France,
Italy, Spain, and Portugal as they jousted to gain or maintain control
over French Equatorial Africa, French West Africa and Dakar, French
Morocco, Spanish Morocco, Tangier, Gibraltar, the Cape Verde Islands, the
Canary Islands, Madeira, and the Azores. Despite the unorthodoxy of his
premise, Goda exhibits a firm grasp of his subject andboth by gathering
fresh material and by placing familiar information in a new contextdelivers a praiseworthy, thought-provoking account.
As early as June 1940, various Kriegsmarine studies called for establishing
naval and air bases in such far-flung outposts as Trondheim, Iceland,
Madagascar, Dakar, and the Spanish and Portuguese island groups off the
coast of Northwest Africa, all with the intent of protecting anticipated
German colonies in Africa following the end of the war. Hitler rejected
most of the Kriegsmarine studies, but retained an interest in the Azores,
Canaries, Cape Verde Islands, and French Morocco. Before long, Germany was
in a position to begin acting upon those interests.
When France fell, pending a permanent peace settlementwhich Hitler
expected "in the shortest time"Vichy France found itself bound by a
pair of armistice documents (one concluded with Germany, the other
separately with Italy) which very imperfectly and incompletely spelled out
Axis terms and the enforcement mechanisms for those terms. Although
defeated and even humiliated, these "temporary" armistice terms provided
enough flexibility for Vichy to haggle, temporize, and obfuscate when
presented with unpalatable Axis demands.
The first of these was not long in coming. On 15 July 1940, Petain's
government received Hitler's demand for eight airfields near Casablanca in
French Morocco on the Atlanticwith additional land for anti-aircraft
defenses plus unrestricted use of ports, French shipping, and French North
African railroads. Although rejected by Vichy and not immediately pursued
by Germany, Goda proposes this as the first overt evidence of Hitler's
quest for not merely temporary or tactical advantage in what was to be a
quick finish of the British, but rather a permanent and strategic position
from which to wage war against the American hemisphere. Why else, Goda
asks, would Hitler, at a time when London was expected to capitulate
momentarily, demand not existing French facilities, but space for the
long-term project of constructing new bases?
Although the demarche of 15 July was dropped quietly enough, the issue of
bases was far from dead.
In September 1940 Hitler issued a new directive aimed at supplementing and
supplanting Italian administration of armistice terms in French colonies,
making clear his ongoing interest in the North African theater and the
Atlantic coast of Africa in particular.
The original draft of Hitler's policy order charged the
Luftwaffe Command "with the preparation of German air bases in Dakar and
Casablanca." Hitler deleted this comment from the final draft, perhaps to
prevent the possibility of a leak to the French or the Italians.
Nonetheless, the Luftwaffe Command began preparatory work for the occupation
of these bases, discussing problems of ground defense and preparing
reconnaissance missions to Casablanca and Dakar.
By the end of September, advance parties of a German commission were in
Casablanca en route to Dakar, collecting intelligence on potential
Luftwaffe airfield sites as well as political and economic information.
De Gaulle's failed Anglo-French assault on Dakar and successful rallying of
Equatorial Africa, however, disrupted the smooth unfolding of German plans.
Among other things, the German commission in Casablanca returned without
having reached West Africa. More importantly, the threat of losing French
colonies to the Gaullist movement in some ways worked to Vichy's advantage,
softening Berlin's heavy-handedness in Africa.
Other avenues presented themselves for reaching Hitler's destinations.
Spain, anxious to protect its interests and further its own territorial
aspirations (Gibraltar, Tangier, French Morocco) offered to enter the war
on the side of the Axis and cooperate in assaulting the British base of
Gibraltar in exchange for an assortment of favors, concessions, and
guarantees from Berlin.
It would take Berlin nearly six weeks to act on the
Spanish offer of 19 June and array itself for an operation against
Gibraltar. Historians have not fully examined the reasons for this delay,
but Berlin's wandering path to the Gibraltar operation provides an
important key to understanding Hitler's war aims. Gibraltar became
important to the Germans not because its capture would lead to victory over
Britain, but because the Strait of Gibraltar provided a speedy route into
Northwest Africa. Once Gibraltar had fallen, Germany could protect
Northwest Africa from either a Gaullist coup or an American strike, while
developing bases on the coast for the demands of global warfare.
Goda goes on to conclude that Franco's offer (and the price he demanded in
return)interpreted by most historians as no more than a ploy to keep
Spain out of the war while avoiding hostilities with Germanywas a
genuine, serious bid to enter the war in the second half of 1940. According
to Goda's review of the evidence, Hitler was willing to pay all of Madrid's
price, but agreement was finally scuttled over territorial issues. The
Fuehrer was fully prepared to trade French Morocco to Spain for a single
island in the Canariesto be developed as a German air and naval base
for projecting power toward the western hemispherebut Franco demurred.
Goda delves deeply into this subject with new research in Spanish archives,
revisiting the story of the meeting between Hitler and Franco at Hendaye
(and dismissing the myth of Franco's intentionally late arrival), measuring
Spain's economic demands against Germany's willingness to provide them, and
evaluating Spanish military preparations in the islands and in Spanish
Morocco as well as Portuguese defenses in the Azores, Cape Verde Islands,
and Madeira.
Similarly, the book investigates German military planning for seizing and
holding the Atlantic islands under varying diplomatic conditions but always
with an eye to future needs and future enemies.
"The Fuehrer," wrote [Major Sigismund Freiherr]
Falkenstein [Luftwaffe liaison to Warlimont in OKW] to the Luftwaffe
operations staff when requesting data [in November 1940], "is engaged in
the question of occupation of the Atlantic Islands in the view of a future
war against America."...Hitler called upon them to take the islands by
force in a hostile sea.
The original military studies revealed the cold, hard facts. It might be
possible to take the main islands, and only those, by force of arms, but it
would be impossible to take the many smaller islands. It would be equally
impossible to supply German garrisons in the Atlantic by air or sea and the
British would inevitably use their naval superiority and bases in the
smaller islands to win back any German outposts. Subsequent studies by the
Kriegsmarine and Luftwaffe, assuming military cooperation with Spain and
Vichy (including German use of French bases and cargo ships) and Portuguese
submissiveness, all to be gained through diplomatic means by Berlin, were
considerably more optimistic.
From June 1940 through June 1941 Hitler pursued a start-and-start,
twist-and-turn path toward the coast of Northwest Africa and the Atlantic
islands. As the wider strategic situation evolved, so his plans and
ideas evolved. Willing in turn to deal with Italy, Vichy, and Spain at the expense
of the others, he was ultimately unable to reconcile the overlapping and
competing claims of all the players in the diplomatic game. By the spring
of 1941 Hitler reasoned that upon completion of his brief campaign of
conquest against the Soviet Union he would turn back to the question of
Africa and the islands to settle the issue once and for all.
In the end, all of Hitler's grand designs failed. There would be no
colonial territory for Germany in Africa. No bases in the Atlantic islands.
No airfields in French Morocco or Dakar. Not even sufficient Vichy military
strength and political will to defend French North Africa. Thus, in
November 1942 Operation Torch made Morocco a base of offensive military
operations not for the Wehrmacht, but for the Allies.
Although it cannot be said that the book indisputably proves the thesis
that Hitler intended to build and use bases in Northwest Africa and the
Atlantic islands against America when his war transformed into one for global
supremacy, Goda's grand tour of Hitler's planning at least demonstrates how
Berlin attached more importance to the theater than is generally
recognized. In that sense, the factual underpinnings of Tomorrow the
World far, far outweigh its more speculative aspects.
A splendid book, perfect for those who enjoy studying World War II rather
than having it spoon fed to them.
Available from online booksellers, local bookshops, or directly from Texas A&M University Press.
Thanks to Texas A&M for providing this review copy.
Read and submit feedback
Reviewed 18 June 1998
Copyright © 1998 by Bill Stone
May not be reproduced in any form without written permission of Stone & Stone
|